Most Expensive 1996 Collector's Choice You Make Play Baseball Cards

Most Expensive 1996 Collector's Choice You Make Play card list & price guide. Ungraded & graded values for all 1996-97 Upper Deck Collector's Choice You Make Play Baseball Cards.

Click on any card to see more graded card prices, historic prices, and past sales.

Prices are updated daily based upon 1996 Collector's Choice You Make Play listings that sold on eBay and our marketplace. Read our methodology.

Shortcuts: Most Expensive, Cheapest, List by Card #

You own: 0 / 95 items 0% Track your collection for free

SportsCardsPro Index: 1996 Collector's Choice You Make Play

Average ungraded base card value (excludes parallels) for 1996 Collector's Choice You Make Play | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

Sort & Filter +

Sort by

Card Number


Rookies Only

Variants

Images

Collection



You can filter lists by card number and rookie cards.

You can change the sort order too. This will be remembered as your default for future visits.
Ok
  Card Ungraded ▼ Grade 9 PSA 10
Kirby Puckett [You Make, Play Groundout] #32 $33.51
  • + Wishlist
Ozzie Smith [Groundout Gold Signature] #38 $12.04
  • + Wishlist
Kirby Puckett [Walk Gold Signature] #32 $11.00 $54.26 $279.56
  • + Wishlist
Cal Ripken Jr. [Homerun Gold Signature] #33 $10.00
  • + Wishlist
Don Mattingly [Double Gold Signature] #23 $8.39
  • + Wishlist
Ozzie Smith [Groundout] #38 $6.80
  • + Wishlist
Cal Ripken Jr. [Double Gold Signature] #33 $6.00
  • + Wishlist
Frank Thomas [Walk Gold Signature] #40 $5.99
  • + Wishlist
Alex Rodriguez [Strikeout Gold Signature] #34 $5.00
  • + Wishlist
Greg Maddux [Single Gold Signature] #22 $4.50
  • + Wishlist
Don Mattingly [Flyout Gold Signature] #23 $4.39 $27.54 $128.92
  • + Wishlist
Kirby Puckett [Groundout Gold Signature] #32 $4.36
  • + Wishlist
Greg Maddux [Strikeout Gold Signature] #22 $4.25
  • + Wishlist
Barry Bonds [Strike Out Gold Signature] #8 $4.25
  • + Wishlist
Wade Boggs [Single] #1 $3.25
  • + Wishlist
Wade Boggs [Groundout Gold Signature] #7 $3.12
  • + Wishlist
Gary Sheffield [Single Gold Signature] #36 $2.99
  • + Wishlist
Juan Gonzalez [Flyout Gold Signature] #15 $2.85
  • + Wishlist
Ken Griffey Jr. [Hit By Pitch Gold Signature] #16 $2.84
  • + Wishlist
Chipper Jones [Walk Gold Signature] #19 $2.25 $19.05 $81.05
  • + Wishlist
Cal Ripken Jr. [Double] #33 $2.00
  • + Wishlist
Barry Bonds [Strikeout] #8 $1.69
  • + Wishlist
Ozzie Smith [Single] #38 $1.60
  • + Wishlist
Jeff Bagwell #3a $1.49
  • + Wishlist
Eddie Murray [Sacrifice Fly] #28 $1.05
  • + Wishlist
Ken Griffey Jr. [Home Run Gold Signature] #16 $0.99
  • + Wishlist
Wade Boggs [Groundout] #7 $0.25
  • + Wishlist
Craig Biggio [Single] #6 $0.25
  • + Wishlist
Tony Gwynn [Single] #17 $0.25
  • + Wishlist
Craig Biggio (Strikeout) #6 $0.25
  • + Wishlist
Fred McGriff [You Make, Play Homerun] #24
  • + Wishlist
Jose Canseco [Strikeout Gold Signature] #10
  • + Wishlist
Randy Johnson [You Make the Play Gold] #18
  • + Wishlist
Chipper Jones [Strikeout] #19
  • + Wishlist
Chipper Jones [Walk] #19
  • + Wishlist
Randy Johnson [Strikeout] #18
  • + Wishlist
Barry Larkin [Stolen Base] #20
  • + Wishlist
Barry Larkin [You Make, Play Groundout] #20
  • + Wishlist
Tony Gwynn [You Make, Play Groundout] #17
  • + Wishlist
Ken Griffey Jr. [You Make, Play Homerun] #16
  • + Wishlist
Greg Maddux [You Make, Play Single] #22
  • + Wishlist
Greg Maddux [You Make, Play Strikeout] #22
  • + Wishlist
Ken Griffey Jr. [You Make, Play Hit By Pitch] #16 $71.01
  • + Wishlist
Juan Gonzalez [You Make, Play ] #15
  • + Wishlist
Don Mattingly [You Make, Play Double] #23
  • + Wishlist
Don Mattingly [You Make, Play Flyout] #23
  • + Wishlist
Juan Gonzalez [Double Gold Signature] #15
  • + Wishlist
Mark McGwire [You Make/PL. S.Out GD.Sig] #25
  • + Wishlist
Mark McGwire [You Make, Play Homerun] #25
  • + Wishlist
Mark McGwire [You Make, Play Strikeout] #25
  • + Wishlist

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a sports card photo. Find the best match in our database.

Example Photos

Great Photo
great photo example
  • Clear Photo
  • Rectangle Shaped Card
  • Minimal Background
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: too much background and blurry
  • Too Much Background
  • Blurry
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: angled edges
  • Shot From an Angle So
    Card is Not a Rectangle
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: cutoff
  • Cutoff Part of Card

Best Matches