Most Expensive 1986 Topps Football Cards

Most Expensive 1986 Topps card list & price guide. Ungraded & graded values for all '86 Topps Football Cards.

Click on any card to see more graded card prices, historic prices, and past sales.

Prices are updated based upon 1986 Topps listings that sold on eBay and other marketplaces.

Shortcuts: Checklist by #, Most Expensive, Cheapest

You own: 0 / 409 items 0% Track your collection for free

SportsCardsPro Index: 1986 Topps

Average ungraded base card value (excludes parallels) for 1986 Topps | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

More Filters ⮟
  Card Ungraded ▼ Grade 9 PSA 10
Complete Set $169.24
  • + Wishlist
Jerry Rice #161 [RC] $52.16 $1,440.99 $75,000.01
  • + Wishlist
Steve Young #374 [RC] $7.51 $1,087.50 $3,721.64
  • + Wishlist
Reggie White #275 [RC] $6.90 $194.37 $5,891.63
  • + Wishlist
Joe Montana #156 $3.91 $176.50 $3,353.00
  • + Wishlist
Bruce Smith #389 [RC] $3.90 $144.17 $5,040.00
  • + Wishlist
William Perry #20 [RC] $3.77 $260.16 $948.74
  • + Wishlist
Walter Payton #11 $3.48 $94.96 $1,760.00
  • + Wishlist
Bernie Kosar #187 [RC] $3.00 $76.56 $1,225.00
  • + Wishlist
Passing Leaders [K.O'Brien, J.Montana] #225 $2.99 $37.53
  • + Wishlist
Andre Reed #388 [RC] $2.99 $51.24 $1,440.00
  • + Wishlist
Dan Marino #45 [RC] $2.90 $41.80 $1,100.00
  • + Wishlist
Walter Payton #7 $2.49 $34.95 $241.75
  • + Wishlist
Boomer Esiason #255 [RC] $2.47 $109.00 $1,128.45
  • + Wishlist
John Elway #112 $2.45 $46.00 $2,237.88
  • + Wishlist
Bears Team [Walter Payton] #9 $2.38 $55.00 $273.01
  • + Wishlist
Mark Bavaro #144 [RC] $2.33 $91.85 $128.25
  • + Wishlist
Anthony Carter #297 [RC] $2.31 $25.34 $126.65
  • + Wishlist
Jim McMahon #10 $2.23 $65.00 $142.28
  • + Wishlist
Lawrence Taylor #151 $2.21 $49.99 $1,265.24
  • + Wishlist
Buster Rhymes #296 [RC] $2.07 $76.50 $399.99
  • + Wishlist
Karl Mecklenburg #119 [RC] $2.06 $49.86 $335.23
  • + Wishlist
Wilber Marshall #25 [RC] $2.00 $52.99 $245.82
  • + Wishlist
Pittsburgh Steelers #280 $1.99
  • + Wishlist
Dolphins Team [Dan Marino] #44 $1.95 $24.00 $100.00
  • + Wishlist
Keith Millard #299 [RC] $1.90 $60.23 $699.99
  • + Wishlist
Atlanta Falcons #360 $1.90
  • + Wishlist
san francisco 49ers [chewing gum] #155 $1.90
  • + Wishlist
Eric Dickerson #78 $1.86 $58.60 $742.05
  • + Wishlist
Al Toon #101 [RC] $1.84 $30.57 $899.95
  • + Wishlist
Joe Nash #207 $1.80 $11.99 $142.95
  • + Wishlist
Dave Krieg #201 $1.80 $13.97 $82.50
  • + Wishlist
Willie Gault #13 $1.79 $77.47 $223.75
  • + Wishlist
Frank Minnifield #198 [RC] $1.77 $36.00 $349.99
  • + Wishlist
Fred Smerlas #390 $1.77 $20.57 $300.00
  • + Wishlist
Billy Sims #244 $1.77 $29.44 $282.27
  • + Wishlist
Gary Clark #176 [RC] $1.76 $25.56 $131.51
  • + Wishlist
Bengals Team [Boomer Esiason] #254 $1.75 $60.00 $139.50
  • + Wishlist
Kevin Mack #188 [RC] $1.75 $27.99 $124.41
  • + Wishlist
Mark Gastineau #105 $1.75 $25.01 $307.50
  • + Wishlist
Scoring Leaders #228 $1.75
  • + Wishlist
Art Monk #175 $1.75 $20.80 $335.00
  • + Wishlist
Bart Oates #147 [RC] $1.75 $38.50 $124.42
  • + Wishlist
Tony Dorsett #126 $1.74 $87.27 $341.94
  • + Wishlist
Bill Fralic #367 [RC] $1.74 $26.00 $194.23
  • + Wishlist
Super Bowl XX #8 $1.74 $35.85 $152.51
  • + Wishlist
George Adams #140 [RC] $1.73 $17.99
  • + Wishlist
Gary Fencik #28 $1.72 $27.00 $130.50
  • + Wishlist
Jay Hilgenberg #17 [RC] $1.72 $76.00 $122.88
  • + Wishlist
Todd Christensen #64 $1.72 $29.06 $122.81
  • + Wishlist

Sort By

Filters

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a sports card photo. Find the best match in our database.

Example Photos

Great Photo
great photo example
  • Clear Photo
  • Rectangle Shaped Card
  • Minimal Background
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: too much background and blurry
  • Too Much Background
  • Blurry
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: angled edges
  • Shot From an Angle So
    Card is Not a Rectangle
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: cutoff
  • Cutoff Part of Card

Best Matches