Prices for 1991 Pro Set Football Cards

1991 Pro Set card list & price guide. Ungraded & graded values for all '91 Pro Set Football Cards.

Click on any card to see more graded card prices, historic prices, and past sales.

Prices are updated daily based upon 1991 Pro Set listings that sold on eBay and our marketplace. Read our methodology.

SportsCardsPro Index: 1991 Pro Set

Average ungraded base card value (excludes parallels) for 1991 Pro Set (details)

Sort & Filter ▼

Sort by

Card Number



Card Ungraded Grade 9 PSA 10
Emmitt Smith #1 $1.43 $19.99 $64.96
  • + Wishlist
Bill Belichick #126 $2.54 $70.48 $775.00
  • + Wishlist
Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [No Logo] #335 $26.00 $15.00 $149.00
  • + Wishlist
Brett Favre #762 [RC] $1.74 $22.50 $116.74
  • + Wishlist
Roman Phifer #760 $15.88
  • + Wishlist
Barry Sanders #388 $0.99 $14.61 $27.74
  • + Wishlist
John Randle #835 $15.39 $41.97 $88.68
  • + Wishlist
Ty Detmer #37 $4.46 $31.62 $156.53
  • + Wishlist
Earl Campbell #27 $2.58 $23.08 $106.55
  • + Wishlist
Emmitt Smith [Offensive Roy] #1 $1.50 $9.56 $51.00
  • + Wishlist
Emmitt Smith #485 $1.44 $3.99 $62.53
  • + Wishlist
Bruce Smith #83 $1.00 $15.77 $63.74
  • + Wishlist
Bo Jackson #42 $1.27 $7.80 $45.00
  • + Wishlist
Dan Marino #25 $1.50 $11.50 $28.60
  • + Wishlist
Joe Montana #3 $1.81 $18.81 $81.60
  • + Wishlist
Barry Sanders #10 $1.12 $17.99 $37.00
  • + Wishlist
Jerry Rice #654 $1.24 $16.02 $65.18
  • + Wishlist
Bo Jackson [Barry Sanders] #335 $1.90 $18.17 $34.05
  • + Wishlist
Barry Sanders #502 $0.99 $14.82 $49.95
  • + Wishlist
Emmitt Smith [Gazette] #1 $1.45 $16.99 $70.91
  • + Wishlist
Bo Jackson #346 $0.59 $7.80 $24.33
  • + Wishlist
Joe Montana #329 $1.20 $8.97 $28.82
  • + Wishlist
Chris Zorich #33 $2.89 $29.03 $141.06
  • + Wishlist
Jerry Rice #379 $0.99 $14.80 $37.00
  • + Wishlist
Whitney Houston #350 $1.52 $14.72 $61.00
  • + Wishlist
Junior Seau #645 $1.00 $14.83 $58.24
  • + Wishlist
Barry Sanders #39 $0.99 $10.50 $36.42
  • + Wishlist
Tom Waddle #818 $9.00
  • + Wishlist
Derrick Thomas [Error Bills Helmet on Front] #19 $3.50
  • + Wishlist
Raghib Ismail #36 $1.84 $9.30 $45.81
  • + Wishlist
Michael Irvin #132 $1.21 $15.67 $38.00
  • + Wishlist
Joe Montana #387 $1.08 $14.73 $43.55
  • + Wishlist
Lawrence Taylor #336 $1.94 $0.99 $33.50
  • + Wishlist
Jerry Rice #11 $0.99 $14.82 $32.75
  • + Wishlist
Dan Marino #210 $0.99 $14.66 $35.00
  • + Wishlist
Derrick Thomas #188 $0.30 $15.41 $61.61
  • + Wishlist
Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [NFLPA Logo on Back] #335
  • + Wishlist
Eric Dickerson #175 $0.77 $0.99 $11.77
  • + Wishlist
George Young #688 $1.05 $24.35 $113.82
  • + Wishlist
Joe Montana #653 $2.00 $19.08 $87.99
  • + Wishlist
John Elway #138 $0.63 $26.52 $39.00
  • + Wishlist
Steve Young #296 $0.99 $14.80 $58.10
  • + Wishlist
Darion Conner [Drafted 1st Round '99] #92 $4.95
  • + Wishlist
Bill Parcells #72 $0.99 $15.73 $63.51
  • + Wishlist
Jimmy Johnson #405 $1.49 $17.24 $55.40
  • + Wishlist
Deion Sanders #98 $0.98 $15.99 $57.79
  • + Wishlist
Herschel Walker #44 $1.49 $63.00
  • + Wishlist
NFL Newsreel [Super Bowl XXV Tele Clinic] #349
  • + Wishlist
Walter Payton [Team 34] #1 $0.08 $24.99 $164.49
  • + Wishlist
Aeneas Williams #788 $1.86 $20.22 $89.81
  • + Wishlist

Login | Create Account |

FAQ