Sports Cards > Baseball Cards > fleer > 1961 Fleer

Christy Mathewson #59 1961 Fleer

Christy Mathewson #59 Baseball Cards 1961 Fleer Prices

Useful Sites..

PSA $25 Off Code: PC25 Code: PC25

- In One Click
- With Details
+ Collection
+ Wishlist
Buy/Sell
Item Details
Show Historic Prices

Add this item to your collection.
Keep track of your collection value over time. Ok

Compare vs Other Items

Ungraded	Grade 7	Grade 8	Grade 9	Grade 9.5	PSA 10
$4.25 $0.00	$28.77 $0.00	$66.00 $0.00	$157.50 -$0.05	$221.30 -$11.71	$769.98 -$43.07	+
volume: 2 sales per week	volume: 3 sales per year	volume: 4 sales per year	volume: 2 sales per year	volume: rare	volume: rare	+

Grade 9	Grade 9.5	PSA 10
$157.50 -$0.05	$221.30 -$11.71	$769.98 -$43.07
volume: 2 sales per year	volume: rare	volume: rare

Ungraded Sold Listings (30)

Grade 7 Sold Listings (14)

Grade 8 Sold Listings (17)

Grade 9 Sold Listings (6)

PSA 10 Sold Listings (0)

All Sold Listings

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-07-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - Christy Mathewson #59 - MINT - PACK FRESH 🔥 #59 [eBay]	$4.25	Report It
2025-07-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats Christy Mathewson #59 New York Giants Great #59 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-07-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson G/VG X3469932 #59 [eBay]	$3.00	Report It
2025-07-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats Christy Mathewson #59 Vintage Baseball HOF #59 [eBay]	$5.49	Report It
2025-06-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson VGEX X3465912 #59 [eBay]	$4.25	Report It
2025-06-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Christy Mathewson 1961 Fleer Baseball Greats (F418-3) #59 Card New York Giants [eBay]	$0.80	Report It
2025-06-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Baseball Greats (F418-3) Christy Mathewson #59 #59 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-06-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer 59 Christy Mathewson EX #D1,457019 #59 [eBay]	$10.00	Report It
2025-06-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 FLEER #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON NEW YORK GIANTS LOW GRADE Hot Corner Vintage #59 [eBay]	$4.00	Report It
2025-06-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats 59 Christy Mathewson New York Giants HOF SEE PICS #59 [eBay]	$5.99	Report It
2025-06-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats CHRISTY MATHEWSON card 59 #59 [eBay]	$4.99	Report It
2025-05-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson, New York Giants #59 [eBay]	$4.99	Report It
2025-05-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Christy Mathewson Fleer Baseball #59 HOF VG #59 [eBay]	$4.69	Report It
2025-05-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats (F418-3) #59 Christy Mathewson #59 [eBay]	$6.99	Report It
2025-05-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Christy Mathewson 1961 Fleer Baseball Greats (F418-3) #59 #59 [eBay]	$3.99	Report It
2025-05-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson VGEX X3387858 #59 [eBay]	$4.25	Report It
2025-05-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson near mint #59 [eBay]	$11.50	Report It
2025-05-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 VG #59 [eBay]	$3.00	Report It
2025-05-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - Christy Mathewson #59 #59 [eBay]	$5.00	Report It
2025-05-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	CHRISTY MATHEWSON 1961 FLEER BASEBALL #59 [eBay]	$4.99	Report It
2025-04-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Christy Mathewson - Fleer Baseball Greats - #59 #59 [eBay]	$5.99	Report It
2025-04-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer 59 Christy Mathewson POOR #D1,338971 #59 [eBay]	$3.50	Report It
2025-04-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Set-Break # 59 Christy Mathewson EX-EXMINT GMCARDS #59 [eBay]	$5.00	Report It
2025-04-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats (F418-3) #59 Christy Mathewson VG #59 [eBay]	$5.25	Report It
2025-04-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Set-Break # 59 Christy Mathewson VG-VGEX GMCARDS #59 [eBay]	$3.00	Report It
2025-04-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - Christy Mathewson #59 #59 [eBay]	$5.99	Report It
2025-04-07	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Set-Break # 59 Christy Mathewson VG-VGEX GMCARDS #59 [eBay]	$3.25	Report It
2025-04-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats #59 Christy Mathewson #59 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2025-03-31	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Set-Break # 59 Christy Mathewson EX-EXMINT GMCARDS #59 [eBay]	$6.50	Report It
2025-03-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson #59 [eBay]	$12.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-04-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 SGC 7 #59 [eBay]	$21.50	Report It
2025-04-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson HOF PSA 7 NM #59 [eBay]	$36.03	Report It
2025-03-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 FLEER #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON HOF PSA 7 [eBay]	$29.99	Report It
2025-03-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59, Graded SGC 7, Near-Mint. #59 [eBay]	$13.50	Report It
2024-01-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 7 NM (Please Read) #59 [eBay]	$17.99	Report It
2024-01-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 7 HOF #59 [eBay]	$99.14	Report It
2024-01-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Christy Mathewson Fleer #59 New York Giants Graded PSA 7 NM MINT #59 [eBay]	$55.95	Report It
2024-01-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats #59 Christy Mathewson - New York Giants - PSA 7 NM #59 [eBay]	$50.00	Report It
2022-08-25		1961 FLEER - #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON - PSA NM 7 - HALL OF FAMER [eBay]	$35.00
2022-04-15		Christy Mathewson 1961 Fleer #59 PSA 7 NM - ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL! [eBay]	$39.99
2022-04-12		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson PSA 7 NearMint #59 [eBay]	$38.00
2022-02-01		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson Giants PSA 7 NM [eBay]	$42.05
2021-06-10		1961 FLEER BASEBALL GREATS CHRISTY MATHEWSON #59 PSA 7 [eBay]	$19.50
2021-04-21		1961 Fleer Baseball Greats #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON N.Y. Giants NM PSA 7 [eBay]	$29.99

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-06-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 FLEER CHRISTY MATHEWSON # 59 PSA 8 #59 [eBay]	$59.85	Report It
2025-04-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson Card SGC 8 #59 [eBay]	$74.99	Report It
2024-08-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson HOF PSA 8 NMMT C88305 [eBay]	$72.00	Report It
2024-07-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson HOF PSA 8 NM-MT [eBay]	$32.00	Report It
2024-07-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Set-Break # 59 Christy Mathewson PSA 8 NM-MT #59 [eBay]	$66.00	Report It
2024-03-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 FLEER #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON HOF PSA 8 [eBay]	$43.00	Report It
2024-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Greats Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 8 “NM-MT” New York Giants HOF BEAUTY #59 [eBay]	$179.95	Report It
2023-05-11		Christy Mathewson 1961 Fleer #59 PSA 8 - BEAUTIFULLY CENTERED!! #59 [eBay]	$49.50
2022-11-28		CHRISTY MATHEWSON 1961 FLEER #59 - PSA 8 NM-MT - NEW YORK GIANTS #59 [eBay]	$51.00
2022-10-14		1961 Fleer Baseball Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 8 GIANTS NM-MT HOF #59 [eBay]	$31.00
2022-06-26		1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 8 NM-MT New York Giants HOF 💥💥 #59 [eBay]	$50.00
2022-05-12		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson PSA 8 NM-MT [eBay]	$33.11
2022-03-22		1961 Fleer Baseball #59 Christy Mathewson PSA 8 #59 [eBay]	$65.00
2022-03-19		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson PSA NM-MT 8 NQ HOF #59 [eBay]	$35.00
2021-12-02		1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 8 NM/MT FREE S/H [eBay]	$75.00
2021-11-19		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson PSA 8 NM-MT New York Giants [eBay]	$67.00
2021-08-24		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson PSA 8 NM-MT [eBay]	$38.00

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-08-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson PSA 9 HOF GOAT Low Pop! Only 1 Higher! #59 [eBay]	$174.99	Report It
2024-06-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball All-Time Great SET BREAK #59 PSA 9 Christy Mathewson [eBay]	$147.00	Report It
2022-12-30		1961 FLEER #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON HOF PSA 9 SET BREAK 3507683-869 [eBay]	$134.16
2022-06-30		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson Matthewson HOF PSA 9 MINT " PACK FRESH " [eBay]	$69.00
2022-04-12		1961 Fleer SETBREAK #59 Christy Mathewson HOF PSA 9 MINT [eBay]	$127.50
2022-02-27		1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 - PSA 9 MINT #59 [eBay]	$79.10

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2022-08-25		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson Matthewson HOF PSA 1 [eBay]	$5.58

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-04-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer 59 Christy Mathewson SGC 3 VG HOF GOAT San Francisco Giants #59 [eBay]	$4.53	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-01-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer # 59 Christy Mathewson New York Giants HOF PSA 4 #59 [eBay]	$30.00	Report It
2023-04-22		1961 Fleer # 59 Christy Mathewson PSA 4 - N Y Giants - HOF - 373 Wins #59 [eBay]	$19.99
2021-10-30		1961 Fleer CHRISTY MATHEWSON #59 - New York Giants - HOF - PSA 4 (VG-EX) #59 [eBay]	$20.00

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-01-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	CHRISTY MATHEWSON 1961 Fleer #59 PSA 5 #59 [eBay]	$20.65	Report It
2024-04-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 FLEER #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON GIANTS PSA 5 EX [eBay]	$13.08	Report It
2022-12-25		1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson PSA 5 EX HIGH QUALITY Example #59 #59 [eBay]	$24.99
2022-06-13		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson PSA 5 [eBay]	$9.99

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-07-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON PSA 6 EX-MT 04472292 #59 [eBay]	$32.09	Report It
2025-04-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 6 EX-MT Centered HOF #59 [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2025-04-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 Greats Reds Giants Baseball SGC 6 EX-NM #330 [eBay]	$31.49	Report It
2025-03-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 FLEER BASEBALL #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON PSA 6 EX-MT [eBay]	$23.00	Report It
2025-02-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Set-Break # 59 Christy Mathewson PSA 6 EX-MT #59 [eBay]	$23.38	Report It
2024-08-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 FLEER #59 CHRISTY MATHEWSON HOF PSA 6 #59 [eBay]	$40.00	Report It
2024-06-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	BIG SIX PSA 6 CHRISTY MATHEWSON HOF 1961 FLEER #59 GRADED VINTAGE NEW SLAB TPHLC #59 [eBay]	$35.00	Report It
2024-01-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 6 HOF Giants #59 [eBay]	$44.99	Report It
2023-12-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson MLB PSA 6 EX - MT!! #59 [eBay]	$26.10	Report It
2023-09-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1961 Fleer Baseball Greats- CHRISTY MATHEWSON #59 -New York Giants - PSA 6 EX-MT [eBay]	$45.00	Report It
2023-04-20		1961 Fleer # 59 Christy Mathewson PSA 6 EX-MT - N Y Giants - 373 Wins #59 [eBay]	$34.95
2022-06-27		1961 Fleer Christy Mathewson #59 PSA 6 New York Giants HOF #59 [eBay]	$49.95
2022-04-24		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson New York Giants Original Baseball Card PSA 6 #59 [eBay]	$29.99
2022-01-19		1961 Fleer #59 Christy Mathewson New York Giants Original Baseball Card PSA 6 #59 [eBay]	$29.99
2021-07-09		1961 Fleer Baseball Card #59, Christy Mathewson, HOF, PSA 6 EX-MT, Giants 59 [eBay]	$20.72

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

Click tabs to see historic sales data.
Click on a listing to see full details. Ok

Christy Mathewson #59 (1961 Fleer) Details

Is Rookie Card:	No
Genre:	Baseball Card
Publisher:	Fleer
Card Number:	#59
Print Run:	n/a
Notes:	none

ePID (eBay):	16055915652
PriceCharting ID:	1835289

Description:	none

More Photos: 1961 Fleer: Christy Mathewson #59 | Baseball Cards

Main Image | Christy Mathewson Baseball Cards 1961 Fleer

Main Image

Full Price Guide: Christy Mathewson #59 (1961 Fleer)

Ungraded	$4.25
Grade 1	$5.58
Grade 2	$4.00
Grade 3	$4.53
Grade 4	$18.00
Grade 5	$20.59
Grade 6	$23.00
Grade 7	$28.77
Grade 8	$66.00
Grade 9	$157.50
Grade 9.5	$221.30
SGC 10	$462.00
CGC 10	$616.00
PSA 10	$769.98
BGS 10	$1,001.00
BGS 10 Black	$5,005.00
CGC 10 Pristine	$1,109.00

All prices are the current market price.

Christy Mathewson #59 (1961 Fleer | Baseball Cards) prices are based on the historic sales. The prices shown are calculated using our proprietary algorithm.
Historic sales data are completed sales with a buyer and a seller agreeing on a price. We do not factor unsold items into our prices.
Chart shows the price of Christy Mathewson #59 at the end of each month going back as long as we have tracked the item.

Christy Mathewson #59 Baseball Cards 1961 Fleer

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a sports card photo. Find the best match in our database.

Take/Upload Photo

Example Photos

Great Photo

great photo example

Clear Photo
Rectangle Shaped Card
Minimal Background

Bad Photo = Poor Result

bad photo: too much background and blurry

Too Much Background
Blurry

Bad Photo = Poor Result

bad photo: angled edges

Shot From an Angle So
Card is Not a Rectangle

Bad Photo = Poor Result

bad photo: cutoff

Cutoff Part of Card

See all variants for this card

See all variants for this card

See all variants for this card

See all variants for this card

See all variants for this card