Sports Cards > Baseball Cards > donruss > 1986 Donruss

Paul O'Neill #37 [Rookie] 1986 Donruss

Paul O'Neill #37 Baseball Cards 1986 Donruss Prices

Useful Sites..

PSA $25 Off Code: PC25 Code: PC25

Fanatics

- In One Click
- With Details
+ Collection
+ Wishlist
Buy/Sell
Item Details
Show Historic Prices

Add this item to your collection.
Keep track of your collection value over time. Ok

Compare vs Other Items

Ungraded	Grade 7	Grade 8	Grade 9	Grade 9.5	PSA 10
$2.32 -$0.06	$7.56 +$0.53	$10.96 +$0.23	$21.67 -$0.03	$29.50 $0.00	$103.32 $0.00	+
volume: 1 sale per day	volume: 3 sales per year	volume: 1 sale per month	volume: 1 sale per month	volume: 1 sale per year	volume: 1 sale per month	+

Grade 9	Grade 9.5	PSA 10
$21.67 -$0.03	$29.50 $0.00	$103.32 $0.00
volume: 1 sale per month	volume: 1 sale per year	volume: 1 sale per month

Ungraded Sold Listings (30)

Grade 7 Sold Listings (9)

Grade 8 Sold Listings (30)

Grade 9 Sold Listings (30)

PSA 10 Sold Listings (30)

All Sold Listings

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-10-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rookie #37 #37 [eBay]	$3.00	Report It
2025-10-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 (RC) - Near Mint or Better #37 [eBay]	$0.25	Report It
2025-10-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Paul O'Neill RC 1986 Donruss #37 Cincinnati Reds Baseball Card #37 [eBay]	$3.50	Report It
2025-10-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 (RC) #37 [eBay]	$1.00	Report It
2025-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill #37 [eBay]	$2.00	Report It
2025-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O’Neill RC #37 [eBay]	$2.00	Report It
2025-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds #37 [eBay]	$2.79	Report It
2025-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Baseball / Paul O'Neill RC #37 #37 [eBay]	$2.99	Report It
2025-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Paul O'Neill #37 NM or better .S92 #37 [eBay]	$2.50	Report It
2025-10-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Paul O'Neill 1986 Donruss Rookie Card Cincinnati Reds #37 RC New York Yankees #37 [eBay]	$2.95	Report It
2025-10-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Paul O'Neill #37 ROOKIE CARD!🔥🔥 #37 [eBay]	$2.99	Report It
2025-10-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Rated Rookie Baseball Card Paul O'Neill #37 (RC) Cincinnati Reds #37 [eBay]	$2.49	Report It
2025-09-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	PAUL O'NEILL 1986 Donruss Rated #37 - NM+ - Cincinnati #37 [eBay]	$2.48	Report It
2025-09-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	⚾1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Rookie Card RC⚾Near Mint⚾ #37 [eBay]	$2.79	Report It
2025-09-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Baseball Paul O'Neill #37 Rookie RR, RC — Reds / Yankees NMT #37 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-09-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Rated Rookie - Paul O'Neill (#37) Cincinnati Reds [eBay]	$3.00	Report It
2025-09-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 #37 [eBay]	$1.49	Report It
2025-09-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	⚾1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Rookie Card RC⚾Near Mint⚾ #37 [eBay]	$2.79	Report It
2025-09-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O’Neill RC NM-MT #37 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2025-09-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill #37 [eBay]	$1.00	Report It
2025-09-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL (RC) Rookie Cincinnati Reds Baseball Card #37 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-09-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill #37 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-09-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rated Rookie #37 Cincinnati Reds (D) #37 [eBay]	$3.29	Report It
2025-09-19	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Paul O'Neill (RC) 1986 Donruss #371 + 1990 Fleer & 1992 UD NM #37 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2025-09-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS PAUL O'NEILL "RATED ROOKIE" RC CARD #37 CINCINNATI REDS YANKEES #37 [eBay]	$3.00	Report It
2025-09-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill #37 Rookie #37 [eBay]	$2.99	Report It
2025-09-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 (RC) #37 [eBay]	$1.00	Report It
2025-09-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill RC [eBay]	$2.46	Report It
2025-09-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	🔥1986 Donruss Rated Rookie #37 Paul O'Neill RC Cincinnati Reds🔥 #37 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2025-09-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 (RC) #37 [eBay]	$1.04	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-10-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds PSA 7 RC #37 [eBay]	$9.99	Report It
2025-08-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 7 #37 [eBay]	$8.11	Report It
2025-08-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rookie RC #37 Reds PSA 7 [eBay]	$3.25	Report It
2025-08-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rookie RC #37 Reds PSA 7 [eBay]	$5.50	Report It
2025-08-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 7 #37 [eBay]	$5.50	Report It
2025-06-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC SGC 7!!! REDS #37 [eBay]	$3.25	Report It
2022-12-31		1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O’NEILL RC - PSA 7 - LOOKS NICER - YANKEES [eBay]	$10.99
2022-12-09		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill RATED ROOKIE RC REDS BGS 7.5 NEAR MINT [eBay]	$0.99
2022-08-15		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill BGS 7 Rookie Card Rare 2001 Anniversary #37 [eBay]	$15.00

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-10-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	120235611 Paul O'Neill 1986 Donruss #37 Rookie RC PSA 8 #37 [eBay]	$5.50	Report It
2025-10-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS PAUL O'NEILL #37 RATED ROOKIE GRADED SGC 8.5 NM/MT+ CINCY REDS #37 [eBay]	$15.00	Report It
2025-09-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Rookie PSA 8 Cincinnati Reds #37 [eBay]	$14.99	Report It
2025-08-17	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #37 [eBay]	$15.00	Report It
2025-08-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #37 [eBay]	$6.50	Report It
2025-07-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #37 [eBay]	$4.33	Report It
2025-06-12	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Paul O'Neill #37 Rated Rookie: PSA Graded 8 #37 [eBay]	$10.00	Report It
2025-05-19	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #37 [eBay]	$4.25	Report It
2025-04-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill PSA 8 NM-MT #37 [eBay]	$10.00	Report It
2025-03-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill - PSA 8 [eBay]	$23.00	Report It
2024-11-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Set-Break # 37 Paul O'Neill SGC 8.5 NM MT+ #37 [eBay]	$5.60	Report It
2023-12-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill PSA 8 NM MINT RC ROOKIE CINCINNATI REDS #37 [eBay]	$14.99	Report It
2023-09-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill PSA 8 and 6. #37 [eBay]	$24.99
2023-08-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill RC PSA 8 Yankees #37 [eBay]	$11.99
2023-07-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS PAUL ONEILL #37 RATED ROOKIE RC CINCINNATI REDS PSA 8 NM-MT #37 [eBay]	$14.99
2023-07-03		Paul O'Neill 1986 Donruss #37 Rated Rookie BGS 8 NM-MT #NotAvailable [eBay]	$0.99
2023-05-24		1986 Donruss Baseball #37 Paul O'Neill Rated Rookie PSA 8 NM-MT Yankees Reds #37 [eBay]	$19.99
2023-04-25		1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rookie Card #37 PSA 8 New York Yankees Rated Rookie #37 [eBay]	$15.00
2023-04-22		1986 Donruss Baseball #37 Paul O'Neill Rated Rookie Card RC BGS 8.5 NM-MT+ [eBay]	$23.00
2023-02-22		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill PSA 8 and 6. #37 [eBay]	$22.99
2023-01-02		1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill #37 RC PSA 8 NM-MT [eBay]	$19.99
2023-01-02		1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill #37 PSA 8 NM-MT [eBay]	$14.99
2022-08-09		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds RC Rookie PSA 8.5 NM-MT+ [eBay]	$5.00
2022-07-01		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill PSA 8 Rated Rookie #37 [eBay]	$14.99
2022-05-07		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Reds PSA 8 NM-Mt RC Rookie #37 [eBay]	$11.00
2022-04-16		1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC REDS PSA 8 mvp world series reds [eBay]	$3.25
2022-03-01		1986 Donruss PAUL O'NEILL Rated Rookie RC Reds #37 BGS 8 [eBay]	$14.99
2021-08-20		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Reds Rated Rookie PSA 8 NM-MT (06556100) [eBay]	$10.00
2021-08-02		1986 Donruss Rated Rookie Paul O’Neill Card #37 PSA 8 NM-MT RC Reds Yankees [eBay]	$15.00
2021-04-16		PSA 8 1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rookie #37 [eBay]	$12.50

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-11-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2025-10-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rated Rookie #37 PSA 9 #37 [eBay]	$20.99	Report It
2025-10-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2025-10-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2025-09-12	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2025-09-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss - Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 (RC) PSA 9 #37 [eBay]	$15.50	Report It
2025-08-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds SGC 9 RC #37 [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2025-08-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill SGC 9 MINT Rookie RC #37 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2025-08-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2025-08-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rookie RC #37 Reds PSA 9 [eBay]	$16.27	Report It
2025-08-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill SGC 9 [eBay]	$9.50	Report It
2025-07-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2025-07-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O’Neill Rated Rookie Baseball Card PSA 9 Mint #37 [eBay]	$40.00	Report It
2025-07-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$26.00	Report It
2025-07-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS YANKEES PSA 9 #37 [eBay]	$30.00	Report It
2025-07-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2025-06-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$22.50	Report It
2025-06-07	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Paul O'Neill 1986 Donruss #37 Rated Rookie SGC 9 Rookie RC #37 [eBay]	$14.97	Report It
2025-06-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$21.50	Report It
2025-06-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 9 #37 [eBay]	$14.00	Report It
2025-05-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Paul O'Neill 1986 Donruss Rated Rookie #37 PSA 9 MINT Rookie RC #37 [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2025-05-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 9 [eBay]	$17.49	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rated RC #37 SGC 9 MINT [eBay]	$25.00	Report It
2025-02-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill - PSA 9 [eBay]	$30.00	Report It
2024-11-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill - PSA 9 [eBay]	$30.00	Report It
2024-10-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Reds PSA 9 RC #37 [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2024-07-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Baseball Paul O'Neill Rated Rookke #37 PSA 9 #37 [eBay]	$18.00	Report It
2024-03-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill - PSA 9 Rookie Rated Rookie Yankees Legend [eBay]	$19.99	Report It
2024-02-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Paul O’Neill Donruss Rated Rookie #37 PSA 9 MINT Rookie RC Reds #37 [eBay]	$40.00	Report It
2024-01-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 PSA 9 MINT Rookie RC Yankees Reds #37 [eBay]	$11.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-05-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill Rated RC #37 SGC 9.5 MINT+ [eBay]	$32.00	Report It
2023-05-24		PAUL O'NEILL 1986 DONRUSS #37 ROOKIE CARD BGS 9.5 GEM MINT 3125 [eBay]	$26.99
2023-05-24		PAUL O'NEILL 1986 DONRUSS #37 ROOKIE CARD BGS 9.5 GEM MINT 1435 [eBay]	$28.21
2022-08-15		1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill BGS 9.5 Gem Mint [eBay]	$21.67

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-10-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE RC PSA 10 #37 [eBay]	$89.99	Report It
2025-09-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds RC Rated Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT #37 [eBay]	$119.99	Report It
2025-09-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss PAUL O'NEILL #37 Rated Rookie REDS FAST SHIP PSA 10 GEM MT K118 [eBay]	$107.50	Report It
2025-08-19	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$76.00	Report It
2025-08-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	PAUL O'NEILL 1986 DONRUSS BASEBALL CARD #37 PSA 10 GEM MINT REDS ROOKIE #37 [eBay]	$105.00	Report It
2025-08-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS BASEBALL #37 PAUL O'NEILL PSA GEM MINT 10 [eBay]	$99.00	Report It
2025-07-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds RC Rated Rookie PSA 10 [eBay]	$125.76	Report It
2025-07-07	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 - RC - ROOKIE - PSA 10 #37 [eBay]	$98.99	Report It
2025-06-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 10 [eBay]	$134.50	Report It
2025-06-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 10 [eBay]	$89.00	Report It
2025-03-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill PSA 10 GEM MINT Cincinnati Reds RC [eBay]	$119.95	Report It
2024-08-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Cincinnati Reds PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$80.78	Report It
2024-05-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Paul O'Neill 1986 Donruss RC #37 Reds PSA 10 Gem Mint #37 [eBay]	$75.00	Report It
2024-03-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss Baseball Paul O'Neill ROOKIE #37 PSA 10 YANKEES REDS GEM MINT #37 [eBay]	$67.15	Report It
2024-03-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill - PSA 10 [eBay]	$109.00	Report It
2024-01-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill RC PSA 10 Tough Gem Mint Cincinnati Reds 3059 #37 [eBay]	$99.95	Report It
2024-01-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill RC PSA 10 Tough! Cincinnati Reds 3058 #37 [eBay]	$100.00	Report It
2024-01-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 10 #37 [eBay]	$76.00	Report It
2023-12-30	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	PSA 10 1986 Donruss PAUL O'NEILL Rated Rookie RC #37 - Reds Yankees #37 [eBay]	$100.00	Report It
2023-11-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 10 [eBay]	$107.50
2023-11-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	PAUL O'NEILL 1986 DONRUSS BASEBALL ROOKIE CARD #37 PSA 10 GEM MINT GRADED ONEILL #37 [eBay]	$120.00
2023-10-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 10 [eBay]	$105.50
2023-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC RATED ROOKIE REDS PSA 10 [eBay]	$97.00
2023-09-17	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill PSA 10 GEM MINT Cincinnati Reds RC [eBay]	$119.95
2023-07-18		1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL ROOKIE PSA 10 [eBay]	$91.00
2023-07-06		PAUL O'NEILL 1986 DONRUSS #37 ROOKIE CARD PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$95.00
2023-05-12		PAUL O'NEILL 1986 DONRUSS #37 ROOKIE CARD PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$78.00
2023-05-10		1986 Donruss Rated Rookie Paul O'Neill #37 PSA 10 GEM MT Rookie RC #37 [eBay]	$69.24
2023-05-03		1986 Donruss Paul O'Neill #37, PSA GEM MINT 10 [eBay]	$89.99
2023-05-03		1986 DONRUSS #37 PAUL O'NEILL RC ROOKIE CINCINNATI REDS PSA 10 FRESHLY GRADED #37 [eBay]	$85.00

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

No sales data for this card and grade

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2022-08-20		1986 DONRUSS PAUL O'NEILL #37 RC REDS PSA 6 EX-MT #37 [eBay]	$11.99

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

We earn a commission if you click links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-07-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill Rated Rookie SGC 10 GEM MINT Rookie Card #37 [eBay]	$92.88		Report It
2024-09-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1986 Donruss #37 Paul O'Neill RC SGC 10 #37 [eBay]	$55.00		Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

Click tabs to see historic sales data.
Click on a listing to see full details. Ok

Paul O'Neill #37 (1986 Donruss) Details

Is Rookie Card:	Yes
Genre:	Baseball Card
Publisher:	Donruss
Card Number:	#37
Print Run:	n/a
Notes:	none

ePID (eBay):	25055868604
PriceCharting ID:	1917217

Description:	none

More Photos: 1986 Donruss: Paul O'Neill #37 | Baseball Cards

Main Image

Full Price Guide: Paul O'Neill #37 (1986 Donruss)

Ungraded	$2.32
Grade 1	-
Grade 2	$3.00
Grade 3	$3.00
Grade 4	$4.00
Grade 5	$5.00
Grade 6	$6.00
Grade 7	$7.56
Grade 8	$10.96
Grade 9	$21.67
Grade 9.5	$29.50
TAG 10	-
ACE 10	-
SGC 10	$92.88
CGC 10	$83.00
PSA 10	$103.32
BGS 10	$134.00
BGS 10 Black	$670.00
CGC 10 Pristine	$149.00

All prices are the current market price.

Paul O'Neill #37 (1986 Donruss | Baseball Cards) prices are based on the historic sales. The prices shown are calculated using our proprietary algorithm.
Historic sales data are completed sales with a buyer and a seller agreeing on a price. We do not factor unsold items into our prices.
Chart shows the price of Paul O'Neill #37 at the end of each month going back as long as we have tracked the item.

Paul O'Neill #37 Baseball Cards 1986 Donruss